Streets of Hate


Advertisement
Middle East » Israel » West Bank » Hebron
November 20th 2006
Published: November 20th 2006
Edit Blog Post

His panic-stricken little face lights up when he receives the information that we’ll escort him home, sending him skipping merrily down the road on an errand to buy potatoes. This is the Palestinian Authority controlled area of Hebron, and as we cross through Tel Rumeida checkpoint to the other side in order to wait for the Palestinian boy’s return, we soon discover the source of his fear. We... Read Full Entry



Photos are below
Photos: 37, Displayed: 21


Advertisement

Palestinian Girl Palestinian Girl
Palestinian Girl

http://www.palsolidarity.org/main/2006/12/03/sarra-school-terror/
Palestinian smokingPalestinian smoking
Palestinian smoking

...as his roof is occupied by Israeli troops who fire on demonstrators with tear gas and rubber bullets
School Girls prior to attack...School Girls prior to attack...
School Girls prior to attack...

http://www.palsolidarity.org/main/2006/12/03/sarra-school-terror/
Illegal Outpost and Palestinian farmersIllegal Outpost and Palestinian farmers
Illegal Outpost and Palestinian farmers

http://www.palsolidarity.org/main/2006/11/20/tuwani-19-11/
Shopping...Shopping...
Shopping...

West Bank
three days later this photographer was "punished"...three days later this photographer was "punished"...
three days later this photographer was "punished"...

http://www.palsolidarity.org/main/2006/12/05/witness-to-checkpoint-abuse-punished-by-iof/



20th November 2006

Dang.
Be careful out there.
20th November 2006

Thank you very much for posting this story. This aspect of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is too often ignored by the Western media.
20th November 2006

Stay out of it
Stay out of their squabbles, even humanitarian aid can be seen as siding with the enemy. These sons of shem have been fighting for centuries let them be--I think the Western Media is sick of it too. Even though the Land was wrongfully the UK's to give to the Jews, still stay out of it.
20th November 2006

two sides
What you witnessed is one of the many horrific things that happens everyday in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. However, there are two sides to everything. Do you know what "Hebron Day" is? Israelis and Palestinians have been attacking each other back and forth like this for many many years. Jews have been massacred and kicked out of Hebron many times through out the centuries. I am not trying to justify the actions of the few people you encountered on that day in Hebron, or the people like them. But just remember that there is a second side to everything, and I urge you to learn about the whole conflict, not just the Palestinian side. It doesn't paint any prettier a picture, but you will see, if looking with open eyes and heart, that both sides commit evil, and both sides want peace. It just depends who you talk to. Instead of hating one side or the other, try to bridge the gap. You are a human rights worker, than really work on the human rights, for both sides, and help bring about the peace that we all want and deserve. (sorry for the length of this comment, but its a very important topic) -from someone on the other side of the border
20th November 2006

Extremism...
Of all types presents problems, and has repercussions through the generations. Excellent article. I hope Tove's operation goes well and she makes a full recovery. Hope you can keep us updated.
20th November 2006

Shocking.
21st November 2006

Thanks
Thanks for your article - I've been blindly unaware of much of this. Will continue to follow with interest. E
21st November 2006

Goosebumps
A wrenching blog, talk about a dose of reality. Thankyou.
21st November 2006

Wishing you safety
Thank you for sharing this experience - going there is a brave thing to do, but to share this with us is teaching us.
21st November 2006

Be well
I just saw your beautiful Vietnam travelblog (I live there myself ) and randomly came across this one. Talk about a difference. You don't need me to tell you how important and dangerous what you are doing is. Just know that many will be sickened by this scene while others will see nothing wrong with the reactions of the settlers. It's a cruel world. Be well.
21st November 2006

Please See Both Sides
What you saw was the truth, but there are also other sides to this very long story. If a Palestinian blew himself up at an Israeli cafe and your mom or dad were victims right before your eyes, perhaps you would feel differently about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. If you would see Israeli children bloodied, screaming and dying on the scene, maybe you would have a different perspective. As depicted in your posted photos, Palestinians celebrate those who die (martyrs) and not those who live. At a very early age in Palestinian primary schools, they teach their children that hating and killing Jews is right and that they must kill their sisters because their having boyfriends shames their family. Hating Jews is common in Palestine, but uncommon in Israel. Jews do not teach children to hate. And Israel does not teach IDF soldiers to hate Palestinians (I was a soldier in a special unit and I know firsthand). The Jews you encountered in Hebron were stupid and offensive but this encounter is also extremely rare. I undertand your point of view and respect that you doing something about it, but I do feel it will not bring the conflict closer to any kind of resolution. Why not try to educate the Palestinians about who Yasser Arafat (their hero until this day) really was and how he robbed his own people of billions while they lived in poverty. Why not begin by teaching children to love and communicate instead killing their own neighbors and sisters?
21st November 2006

...sigh...
Nomad, you should have taken that photograph... people need to see the raw hatred of the so-called "settlers"... That picture would have woken many sleeping people up... but now they'll say your simply lying, or exaggerating... And to the poster above, you need to do some serious study my friend, it doesn't take much to realise that the Israeli occupation of Palestine is oppressive beyond belief. It is wholly one sided, and if it wasn't for the *occupation* their would be no terrorism at all. It is not palestinians shouting "we killed Jesus!" .. and it wasn't Palestinians harming International workers in the region... it's this orthodox group of fanatical Jews! WAKE UP FOR GOD'S SAKE! I am amazed that the Palestinians are as restrained as they are! What an incredible people...
21st November 2006

Mark
Mark, you sound like a sociopath. Are you writing us from jail at the moment? Good luck!
21st November 2006

Both Sides?
I appreciate the passion in Mark's comment. This is a one-sided issue. I'm sick and tired of Palestinians who fight occupation being labeled as "terrorists" and that Israel's brutal AGGRESSION against these people is labeled as "retaliation in self-defense." In their minds, a misguided Qassam missile into the Negev warrants a full-fledged attack on Gaza where children and women are murdered in cold blood. Did you bother to ask yourself why they are firing Qassams? Because they want JUSTICE for all Palestine. When Israeis stop letting pregnant women die at checkpoints, when they stop stealing even more land to build their ghetto wall, when Muslims and Christians are allowed to worship freely THEN they will have a ceasefire. I'm an American who's been to Palestine and seen this ruthless occupation first-hand. My best wishes and regards to Tove, speedy recovery dear and I admire you so much.
21st November 2006

Stay a few more months
I was there too. This year. As an "international observer" too. I find this article alarming; it's sensationalistic without really understanding what it sensationalizes. And lots of people are going to read this and think it's the whole picture. I urge you to reconsider posting images of your bloodied friend on the Internet. You were correct to be concerned about inciting hate with the other photo you mention; but what you've posted has the same effect, especially now that your journal's on the TravelBlog front page. There are millions of images you could post, to serve whichever side you choose - and much more brutal images, sadly. Have you met many secular Israelis? Have you spent much time in Israel proper? Have you met Israeli young people, many of whom are politically way to the left and deeply resentful of their (mandatory) military service? If you really do fancy yourself an international observer, the responsible action is to reserve comment until you have a more thorough understanding of the issue, and not share violent, provocative anecdotes in isolation. You'll only inflame the hundreds of people who will read this. And do you really think those people have a peaceful, healthy outlet for the rage you will create?
21st November 2006

For Tammy
The IDF is aggressive against the Palestinians ONLY because the IDF are reacting to threats from militants. Unfortunately, some are caught in the crossfire. Tammy, do you think that Israel can negotiate for peace with people who want them wiped off the map? Is it possible to negotiate with people who don't even recognize you exist? With people who flatly deny that 6 million people were executed simply for being born Jewish? Tammy, please help me out because you seem to have all the answers for peace.
21st November 2006

Both Zionists and islamists are fascists. its simple but its true.
22nd November 2006

Real travellers travel should use the slow-lane at all time :-)
Dear Aspiringnomad, Your last entry will be -most probably- the most read due to its very same nature but, let me say, it's also the first in your beautiful blog I personally found heavy one-sided. I understand you wrote it and post it "hot", as soon as things happened and still in rage for what had happened to your friend (to whom I wish a full and quick recover). Still, I believe, beein the theme so delicate you should have waited and in the meantimes, talking to (many) people form both sides you would have developed a less black or white idea. Well, that is, at least what happened to me two years ago when I spent the whole summer travelling in the area. These few fanatic ultrahortodox jews who dedicate their lives making other's lives miserables represent a tiny porcentage of the israelian people. The very same "sane" israelians consider these people as a big problem, as the reason why -in many cases- a friend or family member got killed in the West Bank or Gaza in order to keep them apart from the equally insensate muslim integralists. Last but not least, you and your fellow helpers are very brave, keep up with the good job. Marco
22nd November 2006

Not surpised
holocaust (if happened that way they told us) is not an excuse for israeli goverment commiting genocide in palestine from 1947. I know that many jews don't agree with zionists, but majority does... I suppose that guy in france is behaving like a angel..
22nd November 2006

Take Care
People don't half like to make assumptions about one don't they? I hope your friend gets better soon.
22nd November 2006

Update...
For an update on Tove's current condition visit http://www.palsolidarity.org/main/2006/11/18/hebron-day-06/ This is an alarming story; the Swedish Government and Amnesty International, both agree. And yes I have met many secular and religious Israelis over the years that are against the occupation, and personally work with many Israelis here who are extremely passionate about the cause. I expect most people who read this story will not have a thorough understanding of the issue and I would implore anyone reading this to do as much research as possible to find out what is actually happening on a daily basis in the occupied territories. If people are inflamed by this article and require a peaceful, healthy outlet for their rage I suggest they join one of the many organizations currently working here in Israel and Palestine.
22nd November 2006

thanks for the news
hey man, i feel shocked and disgusted speacially at some of the comments that you received. yes a story always has two sides, what did tvi do to deserve that. she isnt palestinian. and even if she was, nobody deserves that. what about the children who haave to be guarded. how can an adult man throw stones at a child no matter where that child comes from. we need to step up and help these people.
22nd November 2006

She should stick to wearing bikinis
and keep her nose out of what doesn't concern her.
22nd November 2006

observation
I think that people on travelblog are generally more aware of the real problem in the area than the general public in the western world( where one only hears about ruthless palestinians and suicidal muslim martys) and its good that the author has given a lot of food for thought by narrating the other usually untold side of the story
23rd November 2006

No Sides!!
I don't believe what happened to your friend (I wish her well) has anything to do with taking sides! I am reading comments left by travelers, trying to explain the situation with history, talking about one side or the other or the holocaust!! What do all these have to do with a beast attacking an innocent foreigner who is not from Palestine or Israel, most probably is not muslim and slashing her face into blood?? How do you justify religous men devout to their religon shouting "Jesus is gay" or "we killed jesus, we'll kill you too"?? How are those words justifiable?? Is this hatred towards Palestinians?? And how could military stand around doing nothing?? To lend a hand to help someone bleeding has to do with taking sides?? So please, spare me your comments and admit the brutality and beasteality of this man in devotion to what he thinks is superior religon. It's sickening!! Take no sides but analyze the situation put before you.. How would you feel if it was your face in blood and all you intended to do was good..
23rd November 2006

Hebron Street of Hate/blood
Very sad attitude of some extremist jews. They surely are blind and are sure to "miss the Boat" another time for their lacck of "Knoweledge". Even if they thing they are knowlegeable on the "Book" but they can not see for it is God's given underestanding of the "Knoweledge": "For the sins of her (the gates of Jerusalem) and the iniquities of her priests, that have shed the blood of the just(inocent children) in the midst of her, they have wandered as blind men in the streets, they have polluted themselves with blood..." Lamentations 4:13-14
4th December 2006

In tears!!!
Hey Jason. You're entry moved me to tears. I don't have hate towards the men who did this, I just feel pity for their ignorance and their fanatical behavior. NO religion provokes hate or violence. It is only mankind that destroys the virtues of religion. I thank you for moving me to tears, because it shows that you can possess a reader's emotion, that you have made the story memorable in every way. That after reading this, many will enthuse to make a constructive difference to this beautiful world. You’ve made me cry more because of the young boy. Your life, Tove's life have lived perhaps an innocent childhood fill of beautiful memories, this boy has had to become resilient to a living hell. God help him and many a like to find strength and have faith that living angels such as you do exist! Sometimes it is history that binds us to failure, and these men are a classic example. Your story triggered my suppressed feelings of despondency that I felt when I watched the movie Osama. PLEASE watch it if you haven’t already. I have never cried so much in a film. I would feel as much sorrow if you were to be on the other side of the conflict and a young Jewish boy was involved. We all have our inner child, and no child has genuine hate for anybody or anything. Darshni
8th December 2006

thank you and good luck
thanks for sharing your blogs, your recent one about palestine really struck a chord with me im going travelling and intend to volunteer. i hope i can do a little good too.
9th December 2006

Tell it how you see it...
I can't quite understand why some comments have suggested that you've been too one-sided in this journal. As I understand it, it's an article about an event witnessed and experienced by yourself first-hand, and I can find nothing driven by any kind of bias in your description of the events of that day. If anything I'm impressed at how unbiased the article is, especially given the nature of the hostilities witnessed and encountered. Regardless of your readers' political opinions with respect to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, one would hope that they can understand that you are not taking sides by publishing your account of what happened on the day in question. I would argue that anyone who has had such an experience has not only a right but an obligation to share their findings with the rest of the world, and I commend you for doing so. I also think that to put yourself in real physical danger out of a genuine concern for other peoples well-being and safety takes great courage and respect for humanity. How easy it is to stay out of what "doesn't concern you" in favour of a nice safe life - and how many attrocities go unnoticed everyday all over the world because most people do? Keep up the good work and keep telling it how you see it. In the meantime, look after yourselves and give Tove my wishes for a speedy recovery. Best regards, $J
27th December 2006

Thank you
I commend you on your courage and sense of justice. The occupation of Palestine has been ignored for far too long. It is time for world to stop listening to Western government propeganda and realize that Palestinians are not terrorists, but victims of occupation and unbelievable oppression. Thank you for your courage and telling us what is really going on in Palestine.
1st January 2007

Thank you
Like Erik wrote below, thank you for both putting this on the net and for doing what you could in that horrible situation. You each have my respect.
11th January 2007

Nice work in Hebron.
Good Job Eddie! If every one of just walks away from an ugly scene like this it never will come out in the open. U stood your ground and helped those lads out. Bravo.
19th January 2007

Very touching
I agree with Jonny up above...I believe that you were just relating some events that had happened, and that alot of the comments I just read have been looking at this as being in support of the reader's own political/religious/ideological beliefs, instead of looking at it in terms of your friend who got hurt, and it shouldn't matter who did it, but if a third party gets attacked, the authorities should have intervened, and even better, should have stopped that from happening, regardless of which side. I just think that the readers should not fault you for writing the blog, but it should be obvious to many that there are both sides of the story, and just because the violence came from one party, it doesn't mean that you are in any way saying that one is right and the other completely wrong....I hope that Tove's doing fine
14th April 2007

Thanks for showing this truth.
It's pathetic that amongst this audience there are still hateful people who would attack you or your friend. The blood isn't sensationalizing ANYTHING, It's actually understating the realities. That was nowhere near as graphic as much of the violence that goes on. If people don't like that reality, then work towards creating solutions, but the camera wasn't lying. Covering up the truth would be to lie. Palestinians are being occupied, have been for many decades, by Israel. They protest, rise up, are promised autonomy (the same autonomy which was promised to BOTH countries, but only ever given to Israel) and then they wait patiently again for another decade for the world to not deliver what they have promised. We would ALL fight back any way we could or had to, if we were so put upon, repressed and occupied. Think about it: How much abuse do you have to swollow before you're willing to pick up a rock against an Israeli with a machine gun in his hand? As for the Suicide Bomber who blew up some Zionist, let's ask that suicide bomber's family about how he lost his father to a piece of shrapnel that says "Made in USA" on it. When the West stops backing Israel and helping them to have such a great advantage over Palestine, perhaps then they will have to learn to live together. A good start on creating peace would be for Palestine to have a shipping harbor of their own, so they could bring their goods to market without going through Israel's BS checkpoints. I am neither Jew nor Arab... just observing the situation objectively, as a camera might.
12th September 2007

other side!!!!!!!!?
for who say u dont show the other side, i think this artile is spoken about something happened, the guy said only what happend, no other side in that, so i want tell to who disliked show this truth, israel is the only democracy in the mid east (as all the world say) , this means that the leader in this state are elected , that means they present the majority of people there, that means that the majority of israelis are agree with this barbarian way which their govt use it against an unarmed pp, so if there is a scullar israelis reallly who like and orefer peace, how much they are one ,two, one thousand? they have no influence this is the other fact and truth which those people who claim " the other side view" ingnore, try to be real, israel own tanks , planes, missiles , nukes, , and palsitinians own what, kassam misslies? some RPGs, so who present really a threat to the other, if really the good israelis are who govt we would never had this shameful situation there, but like u see your pp reflect the image of your govt cause it allow them to behave like that,? hope so one from who claim the "other side" idea can comment what i said or answer me
11th February 2008

To Everybody: The way it goes
I've read more or less everything here, blogs and comments, and here is what I think. I don't really find it interesting to argue whose side is right and wrong, and who has done this that and the other. These rights and wrongs go so far back in time that they become irrelevant and people commit terrible acts every day: palestinians bomb cafe's and Israelis bulldoze a few schools. The guilt is evenly distributed on each side and there are no winners and losers. What we have here are people hating and killing and this has made Israel and Palestine pretty rotten places. If people really wanted this violence to stop it would, but barbarianism and bloodlust continues to govern this part of the world. Nothing can fix this and that is, I regret to say, the way it goes. Should I save a palestinian boy today he'll blow up a cafe tomorrow, protect an israeli and she'll be getting a bulldozer drivers licence. So this is where I seize to care. These people will never work this out and I think we better leave them to it and care about things we can actually do something about.
20th February 2008

THANKS LOT FOR THIS STORY
THANKS LOT FOR THIS STORY ..ITS REAL I CAN FEEL IT .
20th February 2008

To Ziggy
I'm glad you've taken the time to leave this comment Ziggy, because despite your air of self righteous wisdom your pathetically ignorant and frankly racist diatribe is actually that of the average tabloid reading FOX News viewing masses. Thank you for judging "Everybody's" opinion here as 'not interesting' enough for you to argue about, or taking time to judge the "irrelevance" of the reasons the inhabitants of Israel or Palestine are fighting. If you did however do just a little reading for yourself you would discover there is no congenital historical enmity between Arabs and Jews, despite your belief that the issues "go so far back in time that they become irrelevant". And instead of seeing peoples behavior and thinking maybe this is a result of their treatment, you see it as a "barbarianism and blood lust which governs this part of the world" again you have almost verbatim toed the racist neocon line that violence is something inherent in their culture. Then with almost embarrassing predictably you claim that nothing can stop the killing so you "seize[sic] to care" and that's "the way it goes"..."leave them to it". Again, the tabloid party line; that this is an ancient problem with little hope of a solution...Do yourself a favor today Ziggy: Start thinking for yourself. "The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance it is the illusion of knowledge" Stephen Hawking
25th February 2008

Listen to my advice, man
Dear Aspiringnomad, I am very pleased to hear that there is a brave man like you in the world who feel the grievances of the Palestinian people who suffer so much since Belfor Promise Palestinian have been suffering so much since 1948 of bloodshed, pushing them out of their homes and siege of all kinds till today where settlements are increasing upon bulldozing Palestinian's homes and homeless people and the barrier wall which suffocate the Palestinians people and make him isolated out of the world, and after all this, we hear from a lot of media in the world that the reluctance of the Palestinians against the racist occupation is a crime (which is so mistakenly so called terrorism). Undoubtedly, this conflict in Palestine is a part of the many other conflicts in the world which a solution should be found for and a peace and justice should be widespread among people whether they are Muslims, Christians or Jewish or other religions in the world so that the whole world live as one family born from Adam and Hawaa (Eve). But please advise me, friend, is there ever in the world a power, dogma or a humanitarian organization that can solve this problem in the world fairly and unbiased to any party? Undoubtedly, the only way to solve this problem is first to know who we are. We all believe that we are the creatures of God, who created us, whether be Muslims, Christians or Jewish, and that the sky above us is a creature of God and that the land is created by God in order we all live on it through the system that the Creator wanted, and this system the Creator wanted exists in the Books of Heavens that He sent down to his Messengers, and which the latest and the seal if them was the Holy Quran, which is a complete and comprehensive course and comprise all what relates to the cosmos, mankind and life and show the relations between them, and it is also a great gate to pass to all kinds of right knowledge that relate to this cosmos. I am going to give an example of our real life to simplify the idea: if one buy a device from a famous industrial company, no doubt that he will get a Usage Documents together with the device, this documents includes general information about the device and the most right ways of using this device and the trouble shootings, and where you are recommended to make reference to the manufacturer company in case of incurable errors, and where you are also warned of maintaining the device by other than the manufacturing company or its agents. In this concern, God says in the Verse no.10 in AL-Anbiaa (The Prophets) soura of the Holy Quran, and as I convey the translation of its explanation: ((Indeed, We have sent down for you (O mankind) a Book, (the Qur'ân) in which there is Dhikrukum, (your Reminder or an honor for you i.e. honor for the one who follows the teaching of the Qur'ân and acts on its orders). Will you not then understand?) At last, let us friend, to look in this Quran and brows it, and you will find it from the first to the end to be the miracle of God's speech where no one, whatever of eloquence he is at, to bring out any one similar "verse" of it. Then, if we found one verse of this Holy Quran are a human's, or found that one verse has been distorted, then, we refuse the whole Book. And this Quran, as we mentioned, is a general definition of each of cosmos, mankind and life, and an exposure to the relations within them, and it also comprise all what mankind needs of systems that make him on the topmost level. So, after we brows and accurately understand it, if we found otherwise than what have been mentioned, then we refuse it. Also this Quran was sent down concerning the people in general whether they are Muslims or non-Muslims to live fairly and peacefully within them on this earth. So, if we also find it bound to or one-sided to Muslims, then we refuse it too completely. Moreover, the wonderful thing in the Holy Quran is that It is quite corresponding to science, and there is no contradiction, in it, with the science that come out of a right base, because sciences that come out of right base, it would certainly reach to a right result. Information that come out of wrong or astray base would certainly reach to a wrong or astray result. Wish you all the welfare.
3rd July 2008

Excellent blog
Good work Aspiringnomad. Not at all biased, just an account of the events as you saw them. I hope more people follow your honest example in the west bank. Only then can we really know what is going on.
16th January 2009

"Timeshifter"
If you write back to me with a valid email then I can reply to your request...I was under the impression I had released the rights to this photo?

Tot: 0.077s; Tpl: 0.017s; cc: 13; qc: 43; dbt: 0.0458s; 1; m:domysql w:travelblog (10.17.0.13); sld: 1; ; mem: 1.2mb