"Censorship is Like a Bird in a Cage"

China's flag
Asia » China » Yunnan » Kunming
January 25th 2010
Published: January 25th 2010
Edit Blog Post

"Sleepers" Art Exhibit"Sleepers" Art Exhibit"Sleepers" Art Exhibit

A modern art exhibit at TCG Nordica, a bar/restaurant/art gallery/concert hall run by Swedes in the artsy part of Kunming

The Debate

If you've been reading the news, you're probably aware that Google has threatened to make an exit from China. Google accused Chinese hackers of infiltrating its computer network, and the Secretary of State has backed up Google's demands for an explanation. In addition, Google is frustrated with the censorship applied to its search engine in China. The Chinese government also recently announced that it would begin scanning text messages for "unhealthy" content, and within the last year, both Facebook and YouTube have been banned from the Chinese Internet, as well as many blogging and photo-sharing sites (I access these sites using a VPN that connects me to a U.S. IP address).

With all of these issues in the news, I thought it would be interesting for the 10-year old students I teach to have a debate about freedom of speech. I split them into two teams and assigned one group to defend censorship, the other freedom of speech. After ten minutes of brainstorming, the debate began. As I listened to each side, I was progressively blown away by the depth of understanding the children had of the issue, as well as their ability to express their opinions in
Kumming at SunsetKumming at SunsetKumming at Sunset

The view from my apartment

The Pro-Freedom of Speech team came up with phrases like "people aren't monkeys, they can decide for themselves," "it is important to learn other people's opinions," and my personal favorite - "censorship is like a bird in a cage." The Pro-Censorship side was just as eloquent, citing, "a prophet knows without speaking words," "you can use the heart to talk," and "one person's words can kill many."

Despite my curiosity, I decided not to poll the class to find out their true opinions, leaving them to reflect in privacy, instead. But I do wonder... what do these kids really think? They are all near the top of their class, and are bright, hardworking children. Growing up in a country that defends censorship and widespread propaganda, what position will they adopt as they grow up? In their eyes, each side is defensible. Who knows how they will feel as they get older?

I guess this is exactly why I decided to spend time teaching them. My class is titled "Brainstorming," and the whole point is to teach the students to be creative and think for themselves. As time passes, I've started to feel personally invested in improving
My Living CompoundMy Living CompoundMy Living Compound

The inside of the compound where I live
the children's ability to objectively examine an issue and form opinions that are truly their own. I think this type of education is crucial to the next generation of Chinese thinkers and activists. Who knows what kind of thinkers the country will have in 15 years?

Why I Love Chinese Living Compounds

Chinese society is highly structured, monitored, and community-oriented. It often feels that I have no privacy, a desire for solitude is regarded as unnatural, and the individual counts for very little here. Except, there are some definite advantages to living in a Chinese city, one of which is the Chinese "xiaoqu," or living compound:

I live in a large compound which houses thousands of residents in 20-story buildings, as well as at least a hundred businesses. Because of cooperation between utility companies and banks, I can pay my water bill at any Chinese ATM machine, and my building entrance is thirty feet away from a supermarket, public exercise equipment, a hair salon, bank, produce store, bakery, hospital, massage parlor, cell phone provider store, and bicycle parking lot.

Some Chinese compounds function as self-sufficient mini-cities, and perhaps the most unique aspect is the presence of
Kunming NightlifeKunming NightlifeKunming Nightlife

A crowded disco in the clubbing part of town
medical clinics throughout the city. There's no need to go to a major hospital for a minor problem - there is a clinic two doors down from me, dedicated solely to my compound. Treatment is essentially free, since you only have to pay for the cost of the medication you receive (usually about two dollars). Even at the big hospitals, it only costs three dollars to see a doctor. Although the quality of care doesn't compare with Europe or the United States, it's perfectly adequate for non-serious medical problems. So even though Chinese society can feel suffocating at times, there are benefits from the system, as well.

My next trip: Harbin Ice Festival!

Additional photos below
Photos: 5, Displayed: 5


Live MusicLive Music
Live Music

Some of my friends are awesome musicians, and they like to play at different bars in the city. I like to listen.

25th January 2010

To quote you
"As time passes, I've started to feel personally invested in improving the children's ability to objectively examine an issue and form opinions that are truly their own. I think this type of education is crucial to the next generation of Chinese thinkers." As an educator myself, the only word I would delete is "Chinese" in this sentence. All students need to be taught to examine things objectively. It is difficult in places where such a strong bias is spoon-fed with the daily curriculum. There are so many parts of the world which would benefit if people could be given teachers such as yourself - even right here in the United States, which is where I focus my energies these days. I would dare to place a bet that many of your students speak and write more grammatically sound English than my own native born born students who are reluctant to learn the correct usage for commas and apostrophes and - sometimes - use them interchangeably! Teachers are dearly needed. I'm glad you are. xoxoRASJ
26th January 2010

Loved your blog merrill. Sounds like your brainstorming class is a fabulous opportunity for these kids - and yes, who knows what kind of influence this experience will have on them as the grow up -- certainly will make a difference. As for life in the compound - glad it serves you well! i think returning to capitalism is going to be an interesting challenge! love and miss you!
26th January 2010

Great info as usual. Just enjoyed a wonderful visit with your mom and dad. Hope to have you here when you return. Love, Aunt Roz

Tot: 0.051s; Tpl: 0.016s; cc: 12; qc: 28; dbt: 0.0072s; 1; m:saturn w:www (; sld: 1; ; mem: 1.3mb