DSC02175The train we took to Aya's house. It was so fast!
Aya arranged for us to have lunch with an American English teacher today. It was such a great opportunity for me to learn about teaching English in Japan as well as Taiwan! I am really happy that she arranged it.
His name is Jeff, he is twenty-seven years old, and he is from Sacramento He is currently her younger brother’s middle school English teacher, and he has been teaching in Japan for four years now. He spends part of his day at the elementary school teaching a curriculum that he helped create and the other part at the middle school acting as a teaching assistant/live native English speaker/reader. Sometimes his only job is to read lines out of textbook. Jeff doesn’t have any background in teaching though. He even openly admitted that he doesn’t like kids! He has a double major in Communications and Japanese Studies, and he was an exchange student in Kyoto for a year during college.
So anyway, these are a few things that he said…he mostly talked about what is different, but I will put a (*) where I think things apply to the U.S.A. too..
The hardest part about living in Japan is getting
DSC02176talk about first class traveling.. =D..oh and this is Aya's dad
the honorifics aspect of the Japanese language correct. (You have to conjugate verbs differently according to whom you are talking to such as an elderly person or a student). Some of his colleagues have problems with people staring at them, but Jeff is Japanese-American, so he blends in just fine.
He thinks that the students are shyer in Japan than in America, so getting volunteers for class activities is difficult.
Parents are a bit of a problem; they tend to blame the teacher for problems instead of their own children(*). Also, the PTA has a lot of power and can create change much easier in Japan than in the United States.
Students, as a whole, respect teachers more. They are also more serious about studying because they must pass a test to get into college. The same goes for high school; high school is not compulsory, and high schools are divided according to certain testing levels.
The Japanese school system tends to be hard to work with for most people who have a background in teaching because there is large oversight and control from the board of education. Also, there are no true consequences when a student
misbehaves. The Japanese school system does not have detentions or the possible removal of playing sports.
The Japanese school system does not use mixed method teaching as much as the American school system. Although Japan is moving away from rote memorization, it is still strongly rooted in lessons. Jeff’s elementary students only learn to speak and listen to English; they do not write or read, but later grammar is the only aspect of the language stressed. Aya’s own brother gets great grades in English composition and reading, but he can’t talk to me.
Overall, the lessons are not diverse.
Although Jeff does not make much attempt to connect his lessons to his students’ lives, Aya’s old English teacher, Mike, did. He had his students come over for Halloween, and he took them out to eat. When he took them to eat, his students had to give him directions in English. (*) (the effort a teacher puts into a classroom always varies)
Jeff said he has to teach various academic levels together (in middle school). He also said the lower levels tend to be left behind because the difference is so great.
When I asked him
DSC022431/2 of Aya's house..but it is only used for special occasions
if he knew his students on a personal level, he said yes and no. He said that it is difficult to communicate with his students because their English is so poor and he gets scolded for speaking to them in Japanese. Also, there is a large amount of supervision of the kids by teachers in the community. The teachers will even make sure the students leave the firework festival at a decent time!
He said Nara’s small town characteristics allow for good and well-behaved students.(*)
Jeff also advised me to learn the native language well.
Although I never had a great interest in teaching in Japan, after speaking with Jeff, my interest is even lower. The extreme amount of oversight and lack of freedom would probably bother me. Plus, it sounds a little boring-reading from a textbook! If I taught in Japan, I would have to teach at a cram school because they have a little more freedom and fun. I am really happy that Aya set up our visit, but also a little bummed about what all he said. Overall, I am happy I know this stuff now rather than later though!
We are going
to the firework festival tonight! I can’t wait!
DSC02236of course we had to do the picture booth
1 Comment -
Add Public Comment or
Send Private Message
Hey Megan, this is Jeff. Gee, I didn't know things came across so negatively in our convo! Well, just to clarify on a few points, teaching in Japan is probably the greatest experience I've ever had. I just wanted to point out that it's not for everybody.
The JET mantra is: ESID (Every situation is different). It's the mantra for a reason: some teachers have free reign of the class and get to create lessons from scratch, while others might be human tape recorders. Some teachers barely have any classes, while other teachers go to 10 different schools a month. I was/am very fortunate to be placed in a good community with good assistant teachers and students. Others are not so lucky. You can check: www.bigdaikon.com to see an example of people not happy with their lives in Japan.
I figured you were hyped about coming and only heard great things about the JET program (and so I was trying to paint a more balanced picture). So let me swing things back around the other direction and tell you more about the great things about my job and classes.
The 9th graders are the highest level I teach, and their lessons are rooted in using language creatively. To this end, classes are designed to create works that they'll use to create a scrap book by the end of the school year. Lessons range from interviewing each other on what they did during summer vacation, to creating their own anime characters, to making a survey filled with questions like: "Who has the nicest smile?" that they will vote on. We're going to compile all that stuff and create a book of their final year in jr. high school with pictures I took from back when they were 7th graders. (Well, when I say book, it'll all be scanned and I'll hand out CDs since making 50+ copies of a 30 page color book would be too expensive).
Worksheets are usually up-to-date. I used to dabble a bit in graphic design at my previous job and so now, I create printouts featuring the latest movies, music stars, current events, etc. "Who is this?" worksheets featuring their teachers as well as baseball stars, etc. "Have you seen/heard _____?" worksheets with new movies and music (that I have to update every year). "Who is more/most" comparing sumo wrestlers to classmates.
On my desk, there is a English CD library, where I lend out music CDs to any student wanting to listen to Boyz II Men and other singers I like =). I have my old yearbooks from jr. high and high school for students to browse. I have comics, some American, some Japanese with English subtitles.
In one lesson, I created what I call "Battle Cards" which are cards with various characters that have 4 stats (strength, speed, cuteness and popularity). Each student walks around with their cards and using the comparative form, makes a question such as "Who is the strongest?" They compare their cards and the person that draws the card with the highest strength score wins. It was interesting to see a "Who is cuter?" battle between Darth Vader, Colonel Sanders and Donkey Kong. I also created 'rare' teacher cards with super stats. (Of course the teachers have max cuteness, etc.!)
So yeh. At my school, I have been given the chance to do many interesting things. It's just that not all people get that chance. And of course, not every lesson can be fun and games. Activities are usually the 'dessert.' First the students learn the grammar point, read it in a dialogue to understand it in context, build vocabulary based around it, do some basic grammar exercises, do a listening to check their passive understanding and finally, they do an activity which makes them use the language in an active and personalized manner. While the students are studying the grammar points, I have more of a 'tape recorder' role. But as students are more familiar with the grammar point on hand, we expand the activities. And occasionally, to break up the regular pace, we also use music, TPR, etc.
Outside of school, there are many fun things to do as well. While here, the Nara JETs organized a Habitat for Humanity trip to India. I organized an English speaking fundraising night which had close to 100 participants, with the proceeds (about $250) going to a home for hearing and sight impaired children. In Nara, the JETs organize Halloween parties, rugby tournaments, nature hikes, beach parties, etc. This depends on the group of people around you, and also how much you are willing to participate and go out.
The JET program experience will vary greatly depending on where you are, and how much you are willing to put in. A good attitude and participation will open the doors to teacher parties, good class experiences etc. But sometimes no matter how interesting your class is, there might be some students who don't want to learn English. There are times that when you want to participate and hang out with natives, but you won't understand what they're saying and what's going on around you. Everyone here has their good days and bad days.
And as for JET vs. cram school, I'd pick JET. The salary is generally higher, you are contracted, you have a network of other JETs, and a support system such as a supervisor who will help you with problems in or out of school, you get health insurance, and many days of paid vacation. You also get to experience school, as opposed to private lessons. This means you can see your school sports, help students clean the school during break, possibly go on school trips, etc.
So yeh, hope this clears things up a bit. I'd definitely encourage you to come out, even if you're only out here for a year! There aren't many times in life when you can just pick up and go to a foreign country for a year. (Or maybe for you there are, I dunno). Let me know if you have any other questions about coming out!
Add Comment
All Comments